OTTUMWA -- The Horse Thief Cave might be one of the best kept secrets in Wapello County. Some historical places have legends and rumors surrounding them. According to Wapello County Supervisor Jerry Parker, this cave is no different.
“The rumor here is that when [Jesse James] would steal horses he was able to hide as many as 50 horses in this cave until he was ready to move the horses out,” Parker said.
Carvings in the limestone of the cave have dates back to the 19th century. Mother nature hasn’t been too nice to the cave. Much of the limestone has fallen off which alters the creek that runs through the area.
“In another hundred years this cave won’t be here. You can see the way the water is eroding as it runs through and even just over the last few years significant sections of it are falling off. It’s not the cave that it used to be.”
The cave is on land owned by the county. If you do visit during the summer months it’s probably wise to bring a coat.
“I don’t care how hot the day is, it’s cool here. All of the moisture that’s in the sandstone keeps it very cool. It’s just like instant air conditioning when you get back here.”
If you’re wondering how to get there start by heading east on Main Street in Ottumwa. Veer right on Old Agency Road and continue until you see Cliffland Road on the right. Continue on that road until you see a brown sign and small parking lot. From there you will have to walk about a quarter mile into the woods on a trail until you come to the cave.
TV Station Profiles & Public Inspection Files forKTVO